Al.Qaeda.net

20. The Liar's Dividend

54
20. The Liar's Dividend
Journal Entry
When evidence can be forged, the liar gains power not only by
making the false believable but by making the true deniable.
The first danger of a deepfake is that people believe the false thing.
The second danger is that they stop believing the true thing.
A fabricated video can show a leader declaring war, a commander
ordering surrender, a soldier committing an atrocity, a candidate
accepting a bribe, or a witness changing testimony.
But once fabrication becomes expected, authentic evidence
becomes negotiable.
The accused points at the screen and says AI.
The public has no time to verify.
The denial wins enough hours for the event to pass.
Researchers call this the liar's dividend: the existence of
convincing fakes gives liars a new way to dismiss reality. [20]
The dividend is paid in uncertainty.
War makes it more valuable.
A crisis compresses time. Leaders receive partial reports. Markets
react. Units move. Families panic. Journalists publish what can be
confirmed before confirmation is complete. A synthetic voice on a
trusted channel may not need to survive forensic review if it changes
one decision during the first ten minutes.
The answer cannot be "trust nothing."
Trust nothing is also a victory for the manipulator.
A population that believes no evidence can be authenticated
becomes dependent on tribe, charisma, fear, and repetition.
Provenance helps.
The C2PA standard, for example, is designed to record the origin
and edits of digital media through content credentials. [17]
But provenance is not truth.
A signed camera can record a staged event.
An authentic official can lie.
Credentials can be absent, stripped, misunderstood, or
implemented unevenly.
A chain of custody tells us where a file came from and how it
changed. It does not tell us what the event means.